Best mattress topper brands - Which? (2023)

A good mattress topper can help you get a more comfortable night's sleep, and help prolong your mattress's life by protecting it from wear and tear.

A mattress topper can offer a cheap – albeit temporary – solution to the problem of a less-than-comfortable mattress.

In our latest survey of 972 Which? members who owned a mattress topper, 85% told us that a mattress topper made their mattress more comfortable.

You can buy a basic mattress topper for less than £20, although many cost more. Our survey results can guide you towards one that's worth your money.

If you're looking to buy a mattress topper because you really need a new mattress, but don't think you have the budget for one, we might be able to help. Head over to our hand-picked round-up of the best mattress deals for the month where we've picked big brand mattress on offer. Or check out our best cheap mattresses where you can find a decent mattress at a lower than average price.

Best mattress topper brands

Which? members can log in now to unlock the full results. If you're not already a member, you can get instant access to all of our independent reviews by joining Which? today.

BrandWhich? customer scoreComfortHow well the mattress topper matched its descriptionValue for money
John Lewis
Marks & Spencer
Soak & Sleep

Sample sizes:Dorma (36), Dunelm (106), IKEA (81), John Lewis (234), Marks & Spencer (74), Silentnight (74), Soak & Sleep (34)

Is it worth getting a mattress topper?

Best mattress topper brands - Which? (1)
(Video) Best Mattress Toppers (Top 8 Toppers!) - Which One Is Best For You?

If you can't afford a new mattress, or don't want to replace the one you have at the moment, a mattress topper can help make what you have more comfortable for the time being.

More than half of Which? members who took part in our 2021 survey bought a topper to make their mattress more comfortable (and 85% said it did indeed make their bed more comfortable). A third bought one to help protect their mattress from wear and tear.

Our lab testers have found that a mattress topper won't offer any extra body support, but can improve pressure distribution in some instances such as on a firm or thin mattress, giving you a more comfortable experience.

However, if your mattress is already sagging, or has softened a lot over time, a mattress topper may not make that much difference: it's time to buy a new mattress.

If your mattress really is on its last legs, check out our roundup of thebest mattressesto make sure you get a good one.

Mattress topper vs mattress protector

Best mattress topper brands - Which? (2)

The words mattress topper and mattress protector are sometimes used interchangeably, but their functions are quite different.

A mattress topper, as the name suggests, sits on top of your mattress, offering a few extra centimetres of material to make the whole experience more comfortable. Toppers can be made of memory foam, feather/down, microfibre, polyester or a different soft material entirely, or more natural materials such as wool or cotton. A topper is generally thicker than a mattress protector.

As an extra layer, a mattress topper will give some degree of protection from stains and wear or tear, but will probably not be waterproof, unlike a protector. Think of a mattress topper as exactly that: the top layer of your mattress. Some are washable, but not all, so check before you buy.

(Video) Top 5 Memory Foam Mattress Toppers in 2022 👌

Best mattress topper brands - Which? (3)

A protector, on the other hand, shields your mattress (and topper) from stains and can help prevent damage. A protector offers a removable and washable protective layer to your mattress, helping to keep it fresher for longer. It won't be as thick as a topper. It will often be little more than a sheet, and can be added like you would a fitted sheet on top of the mattress (and topper), or held on by straps which go over the corners.

A mattress protector will help protect your mattress from bodily fluids, spills and stains. As a mattress protector won't be as thick as a mattress topper, it won't protect your mattress much from wear and tear, or prevent it sagging.

Mattress protectors are usually washable, but some high-end, natural toppers are spot clean only: check the instructions before bundling it into the washing machine.

If you need to clean your mattress – for example if you've bled onto your mattress or need to clear up a bed-wetting accident – head to our how to clean a mattress guide for advice.

Types of mattress toppers

There are four main types of mattress topper: memory foam, feather and down, microfibre and latex. But you'll also find other toppers made from more natural materials, such as wool or cotton.

Each type of mattress topper feels different to lie on. Down toppers feel soft, plush and cosy, while memory foam is firm and spongey and can feel warmer.

Memory foam mattress toppers

Best mattress topper brands - Which? (4)
(Video) Top 5 Best Mattress Protector In India 2022 | Mattress Protector Prices | Mattress Protector Covers
  • Pros: helps absorb the motion of a bed partner who tosses and turns throughout the night; designed to reduce pressure on arthritic or sore joints; can make a firm mattress feel considerably softer
  • Cons: some find memory foam toppers hot to lie on; can make it difficult to turn over in bed; usually more expensive than microfibre and down; can have a synthetic smell when new

Made of a temperature-sensitive material, memory foam will react to your body heat and contour to your shape – which manufacturers claim helps relieve painful joints.

A memory foam mattress topper should spring back to the same height each time you use it, too, unlike one made of down or microfibre, which will need to be fluffed up.

However, some people don't like the feel of memory foam and find that it makes them feel too warm. It's worth trying a memory foam mattress topper in-store before buying, if you can.

Some memory foam toppers will smell quite synthetic when new, but this should fade within a week. To remove the smell more quickly, hang the topper up outside or in an airy room to let it breathe before putting it on your bed.

Feather and down mattress toppers

Best mattress topper brands - Which? (5)
  • Pros: won’t retain as much heat as memory foam; won't hinder your movement in bed, feels soft and cosy - sometimes described as laying on a cloud, some feather or down mattress toppers can be cheaper than some memory foam or latex;
  • Cons: may well compress over time, requiring periodic shaking to fluff it back up; not hypoallergenic; feather quills can poke through the fabric; can smell at first; not always ethically farmed

Feather and down mattress toppers have a more traditional feel and you can find cheap down mattress toppers for around £50.

Premium feather and down toppers can be expensive. Some, such as Hungarian goose down, can be very expensive.

These natural options can flatten down quickly and will need regular fluffing to retain their shape. You might find they have a musky smell at first, too.

Feathers and down aren't always taken from birds in a humane way. To ensure you're buying a topper with down that has been responsibly farmed, we recommend checking with manufacturers and retailers to find out what their policies are before you buy.

(Video) ✅Mattress Topper: Best Mattress Toppers (Buying Guide)

Microfibre and hollowfibre mattress toppers

Best mattress topper brands - Which? (6)
  • Pros: cheapest option; no odour; provides a bit of softness; available in anti-allergy options, not as warm as other options
  • Cons: not as breathable as other mattress topper types; can become lumpy over time; will flatten over time; shortest lifespan of all the topper types

Microfibre is a synthetic material, often used in pillows and duvets, and is the most affordable of all mattress topper types. It's a great basic option if you need a mattress topper on a budget - you can pick them up for as little as £20 in some places.

It's not as breathable as down, and will flatten quicker, but this can be fixed by regularly shaking to fluff it back up.

Its synthetic fibres make it hypoallergenic, too. Some are sold as ‘anti-allergy’: these ones are treated with a chemical to help stop common allergens such as dust mites and pollen.

Latex mattress toppers

  • Pros: designed to be very durable; a latex mattress topper will absorb movement if your partner moves in the night; antimicrobial and non-allergenic (unless you have a latex allergy)
  • Cons: expensive; can have a distinctive odour when new; too firm for some; feels different to traditional feather and down

Made of either rubber tree sap or synthetic rubber, latex mattress toppers tend to be cooler and more breathable than memory foam. Latex contours to your body shape like foam, but its elasticity means it will bounce back quickly.

It is usually quite expensive, but manufacturers claim that latex is more durable than any other bedding material, so it should stay comfortable for longer.

Latex has an unusual feel, which is different to either memory foam or down. Some people like it and some don't, so it's worth trying a latex topper or mattress in-store before you buy.

How much do you need to spend on a mattress topper?

If you're after a basic double mattress topper, you can pick up a relatively cheap own-brand supermarket polyester topper for £14.

Entry-level memory foam mattress toppers start at around £20. Some premium mattress toppers can cost more than £200 for a double-size.

Premium down and latex toppers cost more than memory foam and microfibre. And we've spotted super-expensive Vispring models in John Lewis costing an eye-watering £880 for a double-size topper made from British fleece wool.

(Video) Best Mattress Toppers Of 2022 - Our Top 8 Picks!

Where to buy a mattress topper

John Lewis, Dunelm, Next and Dormeo are among the most searched-for mattress topper retailers at the time of writing. We’ve included links to these retailers below, chosen because of their stock availability, best-value price and/or warranty options.

Mattress toppers and protectors can bring comfort and add years of life to your bedding, so buying from a trusted brand is a must. Check the retailer's returns policy and pay attention to customer feedback and reviews. For more details on shopping online safely and arranging refunds for faulty products, see our advice on shopping online.

  • John Lewis - offers a range of mattress toppers, from single to super king size and made with natural and synthetic materials. The cheapest products come in at £40 for a double-sized synthetic topper. Click & Collect is free on orders over £30, and standard delivery starts at £3.95 (but is free on orders over £50)
  • Dunelm - sells many types of mattress toppers, from memory foam to duck feather down, from as little as £22 for a single-size. Retails own-brand toppers as well as products from Fogarty, Dorma and Eve. Standard delivery is £3.95 and free for orders over £49 – all returns are free. You can also click & collect for free.
  • Next - advertises mattress topper and protector products in a range of sizes, including children's beds, cots and bassinets. The cheapest protector comes for just £10 for a single, and prices go up to between £200-400 for more premium brands, depending on mattress size. You can get in-store collection for free but you'll need to pay for home delivery.
  • Dormeo - offers several types of toppers and protectors in a range of materials. 60-night sleep trials are available with several models and free delivery applies on orders over £79.

Last updated May 2022


What mattress topper lasts the longest? ›

A high-quality mattress topper should last from 3 to 10 years, depending on the quality and type of mattress topper. Latex and memory foam mattress toppers have the longest lifespan while natural down mattress toppers have the shortest.

What is the best filling for mattress toppers? ›

Choose toppers with washable synthetic fills or naturally hypoallergenic fills. Memory foam and synthetic toppers are easy to keep clean, helping keep allergy-causing nasties at bay. Wool is also a great choice as it's naturally hypoallergenic and washable.

What brand is the best mattress? ›

Best Rated Mattresses of 2022
  • Best Overall: Casper Original Hybrid »
  • Best Lower-Priced Mattress: Tuft & Needle Mint »
  • Best Budget Mattress: Tuft & Needle Original »
  • Best Budget Memory Foam Mattress: Original Lull Mattress »
  • Best Latex Mattress: Birch Natural Mattress »
Oct 10, 2022

Why do hotel beds feel so good? ›

Hotels beds are incredibly comfortable thanks to their use of mattress toppers. These can significantly adjust mattress firmness and the quality of your rest. A mattress topper is simply an added layer of cushioning that rests on top of your old mattress and provides support and extra levels of comfort.

What is the best brand of memory foam mattress topper? ›

Best overall mattress topper

Tempur-Pedic is a leader in the sleep industry, known for its responsive memory-foam mattresses and pillows. As of August 2022, the brand has upgraded and replaced our previous pick for the best overall mattress topper, the Tempur-Supreme, with the renamed Tempur-Adapt.

Do mattress toppers make a difference? ›

Mattress toppers create a notable difference in the way a mattress feels. Toppers can make a bed softer or firmer, depending on the style and materials used. Toppers can improve the performance of an older mattress or protect a newer one from premature wear.

Is memory foam or latex better for a mattress topper? ›

Winner: Memory foam. Both memory foam and latex are super durable and they each have their pros and their cons. However, memory foam has more slow-moving properties that offer better pressure relief. In contrast, latex mattresses have a bouncier feel that is better for those who tend to sleep hot.

What mattress topper will make my bed softer? ›

Get A Mattress Topper To Make The Bed Softer

We specifically recommend a thick memory foam topper, a goose down topper, or a wool topper for a softer feel.

How thick should Topper be? ›

When deciding on the thickness of a topper, you should also consider the condition of your mattress. If you have a newer mattress, you will be fine purchasing a 2-inch topper. However, if your existing mattress is older, you should look at toppers between 3-4 inches to provide you extra cushioning.

Should I get a soft or medium mattress topper? ›

As a side note, The Cleveland Clinic suggests that body shape can also determine which firmness level to select. People with hips wider than their waist should go with a softer firmness level, while those with narrower hips will find better support by choosing a firmer sleep surface.

Do I need bigger sheets If I have a mattress topper? ›

Because a topper can add anywhere from one to as many as six inches or more of height to your bed, look for fitted sheets with deeper pockets. Measure the height of your mattress plus a topper to determine the depth of fitted sheet you will need.

What are the 3 best mattresses? ›

Best Mattress Overview
  • Best Overall: Helix Midnight.
  • Most Comfortable: DreamCloud Mattress.
  • Best Value: Nectar Mattress.
  • Best Luxury: Saatva Classic.
  • Best for Side Sleepers: Softer WinkBed.
  • Best for Couples: Helix Dusk Luxe.
  • Best for Back Pain: Luxury Firm WinkBed.
  • Best for Combination Sleepers: Layla Hybrid.
5 days ago

What is the best value mattress brand? ›

The Best Cheap Mattresses
  • Best Overall. Nectar Mattress. ...
  • Most Comfortable. DreamCloud Mattress. ...
  • Best for Side Sleepers. Layla Mattress. ...
  • Best for Combination Sleepers. Leesa Studio. ...
  • Best for Back Pain. Bear Original. ...
  • Best for Couples. Nolah Original 10. ...
  • Best Cooling. Silk & Snow Hybrid. ...
  • Best for Guest Rooms. Siena Memory Foam Mattress.
5 days ago

What mattress does 5 star hotels use? ›

Additionally, most hotels turn to classic brands such as Sealy, Serta-Simmons, and Beautyrest. To fully recreate your hotel sleeping experience, you can opt for one of these brands. Because hotels purchase luxury mattresses, they're likely to run you at least $2,000.

What kind of bed is used in 5 star hotels? ›

Upscale hotels usually use luxury mattresses that are either hybrid , traditional innerspring , or memory foam mattresses. Hybrid mattresses are becoming particularly commonplace, as they strike the balance between supportive innerspring coals and body-cradling memory foam.

What is the best 3 mattress topper? ›

The best mattress toppers in 2022
  1. Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Topper. ...
  2. Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Topper. ...
  3. Lucid Gel Memory Foam Topper. ...
  4. Saatva Mattress Topper. ...
  5. ViscoSoft Active Cooling Mattress Topper. ...
  6. Linenspa Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper. ...
  7. Turmerry Organic Latex Mattress Topper. ...
  8. Layla Mattress Topper.
Sep 14, 2022

Is foam or memory foam better? ›

Higher-Quality: Memory foam is a higher-quality material because of its advanced design. This means you're likely to get better results from memory foam when it comes to factors like pressure relief performance, motion isolation, and durability.

How long should mattress toppers last? ›

According to Sleep Foundation, the lifespan of a typical mattress topper is three to five years.

How long does a mattress topper usually last? ›

Average lifespan of a mattress topper

A mattress topper will generally last you between three to five years on average. This can vary, though, based on the type of mattress topper you're using, the quality of its internal structure, and how well you maintain it.

Can you just sleep on a topper? ›

Yes, a mattress topper can be used as a mattress. However, there are several factors you should consider before making the jump. If the mattress topper is going to be a temporary replacement for your bed, then it will do just fine.

Which lasts longer memory foam or latex? ›

Latex mattresses are typically more durable than their memory foam counterparts. Some latex beds may last up to 20 years with proper care, while memory foam lasts around ten years. Latex is a more resilient material, meaning it bounces back into shape faster and is less likely to sag over time.

Which is more expensive latex or memory foam? ›

Memory foam has slightly better motion isolation due to its body-hugging feel, but both materials do a very good job of reducing motion transfer. Latex is significantly more expensive than memory foam. The average latex mattress is roughly twice the price of the average memory foam mattress.

What is better than memory foam? ›

Latex is firmer than memory foam because of its structure. If you want a bed that resists sagging, choose natural latex. With care, a natural latex mattress can last up to 15 years. If you want to sink into your mattress, choose memory foam.

How do you make your bed feel like a cloud? ›

Give your bed an added layer of softness and support with a memory foam mattress topper. Keep the memory foam in place with a quilted mattress cover that doubles as a fluffy cushion. Layer a quilt underneath your comforter or duvet to give your bed a little extra volume. Invest in a down comforter for snug snoozing.

Will a mattress topper make my bed less firm? ›

Adding a mattress topper is an excellent way to soften a hard mattress. Mattress toppers give your body more cushion that your current bed lacks. For example, many innerspring models have thin comfort layers that aren't enough to relieve pressure points.

Why did my memory foam topper get hard? ›

Memory foam is temperature-sensitive and reacts to your body heat. At higher temperatures, it will react by becoming more viscous and flexible, and then become firmer as the temperature drops. As a result, a memory foam mattress feels harder until it is warmed up.

What thickness of mattress topper is best for back pain? ›

Thickness. Most often, mattress toppers come in three thickness levels: 1″, 2″, and 3″. Heavier side and back sleepers will want to look for a 3″ topper, because this will create the most pressure relief. If you're a lightweight back or side sleeper, a 2″ topper could work well.

Is a 3 inch memory foam topper too thick? ›

A mattress topper that is 3 inches should be enough for most sleepers. However, if you can splurge and want a more plush bed, opt for a thicker 4-inch topper. The filling inside the mattress topper will add to the quality and support, depending if it is memory foam, latex, or down.

Are foam toppers good? ›

Pros of Memory Foam Mattress Toppers

Mattresses can lose their cushioning support over time. A memory foam mattress topper won't restore your mattress, but it will increase the comfort you feel when you go to sleep, and it will prolong its life for a time before you have to invest in a new bed.

What is the thickest and best mattress topper? ›

Our Best Mattress Toppers Rating
  • #1 Sleep Innovations 4-Inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper.
  • #2 Tuft & Needle Mattress Topper.
  • #3 Lucid 3-Inch Zone Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper.
  • #3 Lucid 3-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper.
  • #5 Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper.
  • #6 Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Topper Supreme.
Oct 17, 2022

How do I know if my mattress topper is too soft? ›

From lower back pain to muscle and joint stiffness, these are some of the signs that your mattress is too soft.
  1. Sign #1: You wake up with a stiff and sore lower back. ...
  2. Sign #2: You have a hard time getting comfortable. ...
  3. Sign #3: You sleep on your stomach, and often wake with neck or shoulder pain.

Do mattress toppers make bed more comfortable? ›

A mattress topper is an additional layer of material, usually 1 to 4 inches thick, that rests on top of your mattress. This bedding accessory can help modify the firmness level of your sleep surface. Soft mattress toppers offer an extra layer of comfort to soften your current mattress.

Do mattress toppers go under the fitted sheet? ›

A mattress topper, or mattress enhancer, is a thick cushioned layer that covers the sleeping surface of the mattress and goes under the fitted sheet. They're usually made from memory foam or filled with down or down alternative.

Does a mattress topper go under or over the mattress pad? ›

The mattress protector will need to encase the surface that your body is in direct contact with. This is to simply protect it the same way as if you were sleeping directly on the mattress. As such, your mattress protector will need to go over the top of the Mattress Topper.

Should a mattress topper have a cover? ›

As mentioned earlier, a mattress topper cover is essential to protect your mattress topper from getting damaged. Although you try not to spill anything that gets absorbed by your mattress topper, accidental spills tend to happen. Moreover, body fluids such as sweat, urine, etc. get absorbed too while you are sleeping.

How long should a mattress topper last? ›

According to Sleep Foundation, the lifespan of a typical mattress topper is three to five years.

How long does a mattress topper usually last? ›

Average lifespan of a mattress topper

A mattress topper will generally last you between three to five years on average. This can vary, though, based on the type of mattress topper you're using, the quality of its internal structure, and how well you maintain it.

How long does the average mattress topper last? ›

The average lifespan of mattress toppers, including those made entirely of memory foam, is 3 to 5 years. This is only the case with high-quality mattress toppers, whereas those made of cheap materials will only last a year or two.

Does a mattress topper Make your mattress last longer? ›

In short, mattress toppers will change the feel of an existing mattress, improve your level of comfort while you sleep, and may extend the life of your mattress.

Can you just sleep on a topper? ›

Yes, a mattress topper can be used as a mattress. However, there are several factors you should consider before making the jump. If the mattress topper is going to be a temporary replacement for your bed, then it will do just fine.

Do you put anything over a mattress topper? ›

Placing a fitted sheet over your mattress topper ensures it will be less likely to clump up in the middle of the night. On top of that, a sheet will typically be made of much more comfortable material than a mattress topper.

Should you wash your mattress topper? ›

In many cases, vinyl-backed mattress toppers are machine washable. For machine washing, you'll want to use warm or cold water and run it on a gentle cycle. Don't go for harsh detergent when washing your mattress topper in the washing machine. Instead, choose a mild detergent.

Do memory foam mattress toppers get hard? ›

It should be expected that upon getting into a memory foam bed in the winter, it will initially feel firmer, and take longer for contours to form, as the material warms up. Reciprocally, a memory foam topper or mattress in the summer will soften more quickly, and take less time to form to your body.

How do you know when to replace a mattress topper? ›

Regardless, the average age of a mattress topper is between three and five years. Keep in mind: the average age of a mattress is between eight to ten years. Thus, a mattress topper that lasts between three and five years is of good value, as it might only need to be replaced once.

Do you sleep on top of a mattress topper? ›

Thanks for your question. The mattress protector will need to encase the surface that your body is in direct contact with. This is to simply protect it the same way as if you were sleeping directly on the mattress. As such, your mattress protector will need to go over the top of the Mattress Topper.

Do mattress toppers make your bed more comfy? ›

Toppers are a better choice for sleepers looking to substantially adjust the feel of their bed. Because mattress toppers are thicker than mattress pads, they are better equipped to make a mattress either firmer or softer. When made from breathable materials, toppers can also facilitate a cooler sleep.

How often should you change topper? ›

Consider replacing your topper every 3 to 5 years. A wool mattress topper is not easily deformed and remains in a good condition after use for a long period of time.

Should I flip my memory foam mattress topper? ›

Should you flip a memory foam mattress? Unless it's dual-sided, you should never flip a memory foam mattress. Memory foam beds are designed as a single structure. Comfort layers are meant to rest on top of the mattress, while the support layer is the foundation.

Why would you buy a mattress topper? ›

Mattress toppers add an extra layer of cushioning to a bed that's lost its plumpness. If your mattress suffers from being too firm, it can soften the sleeping surface considerably. A mattress topper can also extend the life of your mattress, making it a cost-effective alternative to buying a brand new one.

How do I keep a mattress topper on my bed? ›

Use a Tight Fitted Sheet

A tightly fitted sheet covering the mattress and topper may prevent sliding. If you can't find a deep enough fitted sheet to include both the mattress and topper, you can tuck in a flat sheet beneath the bed, holding the mattress and topper together.

Do I have to wait 24 hours for my mattress topper to expand? ›

Sometimes it only takes a few hours, but other times it can take up to 48 hours to fully expand. The safe and easy rule we follow is to just eye-ball it. Once your mattress looks fluffy and comfortable, it's safe to sleep on and that's usually on the first night.


1. Best Mattress Toppers - Which Is Right For You?
(Mattress Clarity)
2. Is This the BEST Cooling Mattress Topper?
(Dad Reviews with @LaneVids)
3. 10 Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers of 2022
(My 10 Best)
4. Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers 2021 (Top 7 Picks!)
(Mattress Clarity)
5. Best Mattress Toppers 2022 (Which One Is Right For You?)
(CNET Home)
6. Best Cheap Mattress Toppers 2022 (Top 5 Picks!)
(Mattress Clarity)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kareem Mueller DO

Last Updated: 17/10/2023

Views: 6135

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kareem Mueller DO

Birthday: 1997-01-04

Address: Apt. 156 12935 Runolfsdottir Mission, Greenfort, MN 74384-6749

Phone: +16704982844747

Job: Corporate Administration Planner

Hobby: Mountain biking, Jewelry making, Stone skipping, Lacemaking, Knife making, Scrapbooking, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Kareem Mueller DO, I am a vivacious, super, thoughtful, excited, handsome, beautiful, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.